The Jay Atherton Estate Collection Auction

October 26, 2025

5:00 pm

Online Auction ends on Sunday, October 26th @ 5 PM EST

Due to health issues, Jay has decided to liquidated nearly all of his assets. A curated lifetime collection of precision firearms, rare sports memorabilia, signed music history, and vintage Americana.

Check out this lineup of items in this auction! Henry, Ruger, Sig, Remington, & Walther sportsman items. Ammo, accessories, memorabilia, signed autographs, sports jerseys, sports cards, comic books, hunting gear, camping gear, tools, and much more! John Wagner, Duke Snider, Whitney Ford, Jackie Robinson, Warren Spahn, and other great Topps trading cards! Autographed Colts jerseys, helmets, and signs! Godfather, Scarface, Tee Martin, Dale Earnhardt, KISS, Saving Private Ryan, and other great pieces of memorbilia!

Items located at our facility: 4377 E US Highway 36 Markleville, IN 46056

Preview Monday through Friday 10 AM to 4 PM

Pickup Days and Times: Monday, October 27th and Tuesday, October 28th from 9 AM to 5 PM

Gallery

Reviews

670 XC

00:56 13 Dec 23

Nice place,never had been there before

Susan Schroeder

01:39 12 Dec 23

Would highly recommend this company. Gunner and Caleb worked tirelessly to organize and catalog all the items in my late husband’s workshop. They know tools and equipment and were able to identify and label even the most obscure items. They have a large customer base and are the best choice to help you get top dollar. In addition to their professionalism - you will not find more caring decent young men. I will be forever grateful to them for their kindness at such a difficult time. They are the best.

Evan

13:26 10 Dec 23

Class A auction, stayed on track with minimal local interference.
Excellent communication.
Evan
ForTrex Nutrition LLC

Amber Johnson

20:29 09 Dec 23

Very helpful and friendly auction staff!

zachary kelly

18:55 09 Dec 23

I had a discrepancy on a bid I placed called in and spoke with Caleb he watched the online bidding and saw the same issue Caleb helped me resolve the issue great customer service

AJ Stewart

17:00 30 Nov 23

I have bought and sold with Jeff and the crew in 6 different auctions. Have had a great experience every time. Highly recomended.

Chris Chrismond

17:04 17 Nov 23

Caleb was so kind and attentive. Helped walk us through the process of selling our home with multiple back and forth conversation with the buyer. Would highly recommend!

lee, thomas

00:41 26 Sep 23

We took our vehicle there to sale. We had a easy and quick check in, everyone was extremely friendly and helpful. Our car didn’t sale but it wasn’t because of them. When we had to pick up our vehicle they were very accommodating and flexible in making a time to pick it up.

Erika Ostrowski

18:50 18 Sep 23

Jeff Boone is a great example of a well organized auction house. Always friendly staff and questions answered promptly and respectfully. I've bought and sold with Jeff Boone and would recommend any one to give them a try.

Spencer Baledge

16:52 09 Sep 22

Great staff, goes above and beyond to draw in a good crowd and awesome items. Have personally sold items here on consignment and couldn’t be happier with the results! Thanks for the great service Caleb, Gunner, and Jeff!

Jason Lisa Miller

22:54 12 May 22

Their inventory was outstanding. I wish I could have been there live, but I was still able to obtain some things I have been looking for at a reasonable price on-line.

joe welch

15:01 20 Mar 22

Great service! Bought from more then 500 miles away. They were great to work with! Thank you

Kenny Hilbert

15:30 12 Mar 22

I should have give them a five-star rating from the start it was just one of those days I have been going to Mort's auction field since the mid-90s watch it grow to at least three times the size that it was then have got a lot of wonderful great deals at great prices they've always been wonderful to me keep up the good work guys keep making it better I never miss an auction with you guys anymore